skip to main content




Back to all publications
Jul 4, 2019

A Smoother Ride for Lessors: Vicarious Liability Cap Extended to Include Ride-Hailing Services

By Jill P. Fraser, Alyssa Gebert and Portia Biswas

Commercial auto lessors and their financial subsidiaries can breathe easy. Bill 107, Getting Ontario Moving Act, 2019 (the “Bill”), which extends the $1,000,000 liability cap to auto lessors where leased vehicles are used for ridesharing services, received Royal Assent on June 6, 2019.

The Bill includes amendments to the Insurance Act specifically targeting liability restrictions for auto lessors. Under Section 267.12 of the Insurance Act, lessors of motor vehicles are currently liable to a maximum of $1,000,000 for any loss or damage from personal injury resulting from the use of one of their leased vehicles.1 However, prior to the amendments, the cap did not apply if the leased vehicle was used for taxi or “ride for hire” purposes.2 Commercial auto lessors were not protected and could be vicariously liable for exorbitant costs in accidents causing personal injury – even where they had no control or possession over the leased vehicle.

With the surging popularity of ride-hailing services like Uber and Lyft, commercial auto lessors are seeing an increase in leased vehicles,3 and therefore an increase in liability. Although many rideshare companies have secured third party insurance4 for passengers, drivers and owners of vehicles being used for rideshare purposes, many insurance agreements will only provide coverage once the lessor’s insurance policy is exhausted, or exclude leased vehicles entirely.5

The Bill amends the exclusionary provision so that the liability cap does not apply to vehicles being used for rideshare services, unless the lessor of the vehicle and the lessee are “dealing with each other at arm’s length”.6 This is a relief for commercial auto lessors. The amendments provide potential legislative protection for vicarious liability, lessening the financial risks and providing certainty to vehicle financing businesses following a collision involving a leased vehicle used for ridesharing purposes.

The Financial Services Group at Aird & Berlis LLP regularly advises auto lessors and financers. Details are available at our Financial Services webpage.

*Portia Biswas is a 2019 summer student at Aird & Berlis LLP.


 

1 RSO 1990, c. I.8 s. 267.12(3)(a) [Insurance Act].
2 Ibid, s. 267.12(4)(c).
3 Ryan Patrick Jones, “Uber partnerships with car-rental startups could increase congestion experts say”, CBC, online: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/uber-partnerships-with-car-rental-startups-could-increase-congestion-experts-say-1.4778393.
4 Financial Services Commission of Ontario, “Ridesharing, carsharing and auto insurance in Ontario” (last modified 14 November 2018), Financial Services Commission of Ontario, online: https://www.fsco.gov.on.ca/en/auto/Pages/ridesharing-info.aspx
5 See Uber’s third party insurance agreement. Certificate of Automobile Insurance (For Ridesharing – Ontario) s. 1.8.3 and s. 3.3.5
6 Insurance Act, supra s. 267.12(4)(c).

Areas of Expertise

Related Publications

Publications Article
Ontario Court of Appeal Provides Guidance on Vesting Orders in Receivership – and Beyond By Kathryn Esaw, Miranda Spence and Peter Dalglish Jul 17, 2019 Vesting orders have become one of the most powerful tools in an insolvency professional’s toolkit, providing a purchaser with the comfort that the encumbrances contributing to the debtor’s financial difficulties, cannot follow to the new owner. In light of their importance, Canadian insolvency an...
Publications Article
Priority of Receivership Charges Over Construction Trusts – Ontario Court Maintains the Status Quo By Sam Babe Jul 17, 2019 In an April 30, 2019 endorsement accompanying a receivership order made in the matter of Royal Bank of Canada and D.M. Robichaud Associates Ltd., Justice Hainey of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Commercial List held that the receiver’s charge and the receiver’s borrowings charge should ha...
Publications Article
Contracting Out Construction Projects on Your Business’s Property Limiting Your Liability Exposure Under the OHSA By David S. Reiter Jul 17, 2019 Businesses that hire contractors to perform work are liable for the health and safety of their contractors’ workers, even if the contractor was hired precisely because it has a particular expertise that the business doesn’t have.