Back to all publications
Jun 12, 2019

Employment Case Law Update: No Tort of Harassment in Ontario

By Meghan A. Cowan

In its recent decision in Merrifield v. Canada (Attorney General), 2019 ONCA 205, the Ontario Court of Appeal held that a common law tort of harassment does not exist in Ontario.

The Court’s landmark decision overturned a Superior Court of Justice decision, which had established the new tort of harassment. In those proceedings, the trial judge had found that the elements of the new tort of harassment were satisfied in relation to a constable’s allegations of harassment against his employer, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP), with respect to his transfer to a different unit. The trial judge awarded the constable $141,000.00 in general and special damages.

The Ontario Court of Appeal rejected the lower court’s decision and held that no legal authority supported the existence of a tort of harassment. Moreover, the Court of Appeal overturned the lower court’s finding that the tort of intentional infliction of mental suffering had been made out. The Court of Appeal therefore overturned the trial judge’s findings in their entirety and awarded costs to the RCMP.

While the tort of harassment no longer exists in Ontario, harassment in the workplace is still prohibited by the Ontario Occupational Health and Safety Act as well as the Ontario Human Rights Code. Employers must still comply with these statutory requirements and should therefore ensure that their policies and training are up to date and their investigation processes are current.

Areas of Expertise

Related Publications

Publications Article
COVID-19 and the Workplace: Remote Working Legal Considerations and Recommendations By Fiona Brown, Michael F. Horvat and Daria (Dasha) Peregoudova May 26, 2020 COVID-19 continues to disrupt workplaces across the country and a return to “normal” could be mon... COVID-19 continues to disrupt workplaces across the country and a return to “normal” could be months away. As employees remain sequestered, many businesses will have to maintain remote working conditions for a much longer time, and to a much larger group of employees, than ...
Publications Article
Reopening Your Business in a Post-COVID-19 World By David S. Reiter May 26, 2020 Lately, there has been a lot of discussion about what businesses need to be thinking about and do... Lately, there has been a lot of discussion about what businesses need to be thinking about and doing as we all, hopefully, start to emerge from the throes of the global pandemic. On its face, the conversation can seem complicated and multifaceted. For example, how will we interact with one anothe...
Publications Article
COVID-19 Travel Restrictions and Tax Residency Relief By Louise R. Summerhill and Jesse L. Waslowski May 22, 2020 On May 19, the Canada Revenue Agency released guidance respecting potential unexpected tax reside... On May 19, the Canada Revenue Agency released guidance respecting potential unexpected tax residency consequences resulting from the travel restrictions around COVID-19.