skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Intellectual Property | Court Decision

Jul 19, 2018

The Value of a Copyrighted Photograph Is Not Necessarily in the Eye of the Beholder

By Ken Clark and Stan Fedun

In the May 2018 decision, Gaudreau c Néomédia inc., the Québec Small Claims Court considered the amount of damages to award for the unauthorized use of a copyrighted photograph.

The Plaintiff, Alain Gaudreau, is a freelance photographer. One of his photos was licensed to Le Journal St-François. As part of a “collaboration agreement” with the publisher, the Plaintiff received $20 for the photo.

On March 14, 2017, the Defendant, Néomédia Inc., republished the photograph without credit to or permission from the Plaintiff. On March 16, 2017, the Plaintiff sent the Defendant an invoice in the amount of $850.

The Defendant cried mea culpa and attributed the error to a new employee. It offered to pay the Plaintiff $100 or five times the amount the Plaintiff received from TC Media. The Plaintiff refused the offer. A few months later, on July 13, 2017, the Plaintiff’s lawyer demanded payment of $3,000 for pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. The Defendant again refused to pay. They went to court.

The Court considered the amount of damages to award for the “unauthorized use of the Plaintiff's photograph and copyright” in light of the Defendant’s admission that the photograph was used without permission. In determining damages, the Court took into account:

  • The $20 compensation paid by TC Media to the Plaintiff for the use of the photograph (not the copyright in the photo);
  • The photograph was removed immediately by Néomédia when it was notified that the photograph was used without permission;
  • Néomédia did not (directly) profit from the photograph; and
  • Néomédia did not credit the Plaintiff when it republished the photograph.

The Court determined that the $100 offered by the Defendant was insufficient. It ordered the Defendant to pay $600, plus interest, and $100 for legal fees. The Court noted that in addition to compensating the Plaintiff, the damages were meant to act as a deterrent.

We note the lack of any analysis of statutory damages under s. 38.1 of the Copyright Act, nor any apparent claim being made for a breach of moral rights of attribution in this action. Given that this use was for commercial purposes and that the lower limit of statutory damages is $500, the amount awarded seems low, particularly given the legal expenses to take this matter to Court.

Photographers take note – there are other avenues to seek fairer compensation for a work.

Areas of Expertise

Related Blogs

Posted in: Intellectual Property | Blockchain

Insights TheSpotlight
The Ultimate Blockchain Patent Teardown Why blockchain applications are patent-eligible By Tony Sabeta, B.Eng. Aug 15, 2018 As a patent practitioner, one of the questions I often get asked is whether distributed ledger technology (DLT), such as blockchain, is patentable. I naturally respond in the affirmative (with some qualifiers of course), and inevitably there is a deluge of follow-up questions and statements such...

Posted in: Intellectual Property

Insights TheSpotlight
Quebec Court Denies Exclusive Use Of Geographic Location in Car Dealership’s Name By Stan Fedun and Ken Clark Jun 18, 2018 In the recent Superior Court of Quebec decision, 7531877 Canada ltée (Buckingham Chrysler, Jeep, Dodge) c 9531025 Canada Inc. (Buckingham Chevrolet Buick GMC), dated May 17, 2018, the plaintiff alleged that the defendant engaged in false advertising (name appropriation) by using “Buckingham” in i...

Posted in: Intellectual Property

Insights TheSpotlight
Certificates of Supplementary Protection for Canadian Pharmaceutical Patents By Kitt Sinden, M.Sc. May 15, 2018 Patents granted in Canada have typically carried a 20-year term of protection from the date of filing, regardless of the time taken to be examined and granted by the Patent Office or for the underlying products to be approved by regulatory agencies. However, since September 2017, as part of conce...