skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Energy Policy | Ontario | Climate Change / Renewables | Quebec

Dec 2, 2016

Stronger Results in Recent California/Quebec Carbon Credit Auction

By David Stevens

On November 22, 2016, the Quebec and California governments announced the results of the ninth Cap and Trade System Joint Auction. The results show most of the available greenhouse gas allowances (credits) offered for sale were purchased (almost 90%). This is a significant improvement from the most recent auctions (described in earlier posts, here and here), where most credits went unsold. The result is higher revenues for the governments - the Quebec government's Press Release indicates that the most recent auction will bring in around $155 million to be used towards climate change action programs.

While it is by no means certain that stronger results will continue to be seen in future auctions, we can assume that the most recent results will be received positively in Ontario. As we have previously discussed, the Ontario government plans to link to the Cap and Trade System Joint Auction in 2018, and fund its Climate Change Action Plan with the proceeds from the sale of credits (forecast at around $1.8 billion per year). If those proceeds are lower than expected, it is likely that the scope of the programs under the Climate Change Action Plan will have to be revisited and reduced. Ontario's Environmental Commissioner had some interesting comments on this topic in her recent Greenhouse Gas Progress Report. In the Cap and Trade chapter of that report, the Environmental Commissioner's office endorsed Ontario's choice to put a price on carbon, but pointed out risks with linking the carbon credit sales with other jurisdictions (especially California). A key item of concern is that the California market (assuming it continues with Cap and Trade, which is not a sure thing) will have abundant supplies of credits, meaning that some of the amounts spent for credits by Ontario emitters will go outside the province, thereby reducing the amounts available to fund programs in Ontario.

Related Blogs

Posted in: Ontario | Practice & Procedure | Energy Policy | Climate Change / Renewables

Insights EnergyInsider
Ontario Takes First Steps to “Cancel” Cap and Trade By David Stevens Jun 19, 2018 In a recent post, we asked what's next under Ontario's new government? It didn’t take long to get a first answer to this question. On June 15, 2018, Ontario’s Premier-designate (Doug Ford) announced “an End to Ontario's Cap-and-Trade Carbon Tax.” According to the news release, “cabinet's first ac...

Posted in: Practice & Procedure | Energy Policy | British Columbia

Insights EnergyInsider
B.C. Government to Undertake a Two-Phase Review of BC Hydro’s Costs, Competitiveness and Future By David Stevens and Peter Dalglish Jun 14, 2018 The government of British Columbia announced on June 11, 2018, that advisory groups consisting of government, BC Hydro and “experts” would begin a two-phase review of BC Hydro in an effort to cut costs and reduce rates for consumers, in addition to making the corporation more efficient and compet...

Posted in: Ontario | Energy Policy

Insights EnergyInsider
What’s Next Under Ontario’s New Government? By David Stevens Jun 11, 2018 On June 7, 2018, Ontario’s Progressive Conservative (PC) party won a majority of seats in the Ontario election. Before the end of June, the PC party will form Ontario’s next government, led by Premier-elect Doug Ford. Over the course of the election campaign, the PC party released its Plan for th...