skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Canada (Federal)

May 10, 2018

Supreme Court to Revisit Standard of Review in Appeals of Administrative Decisions

By Zoë Thoms

In a recent decision granting leave to appeal, the Supreme Court of Canada signalled its intention to once again consider the nature and scope of judicial review of administrative action, specifically the question of standard of review.

The Supreme Court will hear an appeal of the decision of the Federal Court in Bell Canada v. Canada (Attorney General), (2017 FCA 249 (CanLII)), which concerned an appeal by Bell Canada and the NFL of the CRTC’s decision to ban the simultaneous substitution of Canadian advertisements on American channels broadcasting the Super Bowl in Canada.

The Supreme Court last addressed these issues ten years ago in Dunsmuir v. New Brunswick (2008 SCC 9 (CanLII)). In Dunsmuir, the court reduced the number of standards for review from three to two by eliminating the standard of review of “patent unreasonableness.” The court also set out a new standard of review analysis from the previous “pragmatic and functional approach.” (See here for an interesting discussion of the Dunsmuir framework and its critics.)

Given the notice from the court, this appeal is likely to attract the attention of potential interveners with an interest in administrative law issues. The court will be heard with Minister of Citizenship and Immigration v. Alexander Vavilov (2017 FCA 132 (CanLII)) and National Football League, et al, v. Attorney General of Canada (2017 FCA 249 (CanLII)).

Areas of Expertise

Related Categories

Related Blogs

Ottawa Eases Carbon Tax Threshold While Ontario Government Launches Court Challenge Against Tax By Zoë Thoms and Peter Dalglish Aug 10, 2018 On July 27, 2018, the federal government announced that large industrial companies will face a less-stringent threshold on emissions penalties when Ottawa’s carbon tax rolls out on January 1, 2019.

Posted in: Practice & Procedure | Facilities | Canada (Federal) | British Columbia

Insights EnergyInsider
Petronas Invests in British Columbia LNG Project By Zoë Thoms and Peter Dalglish Jun 08, 2018 Less than a year after cancelling the $36-billion Pacific Northwest LNG megaproject in British Columbia, Petronas announced on May 31, 2018, that one of its wholly-owned entities will assume a 25 per cent stake of the LNG Canada project located in Kitimat, B.C.

Posted in: Canada (Federal) | British Columbia

Insights EnergyInsider
Supreme Court of British Columbia Dismisses Challenges to Trans Mountain Pipeline Environmental Assessment By Zoë Thoms and Stan Fedun Jun 05, 2018 On May 24, 2018, the Supreme Court of British Columbia dismissed challenges to the Trans Mountain Pipeline Expansion Project by the City of Vancouver and the Squamish Nation.​ Both parties petitioned the Court to set aside the Environmental Assessment Certificate issued by British Columbia’s Mini...