skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Ontario | Practice & Procedure | Ratemaking

May 18, 2015

OEB Decisions Denying Full-Year Recovery of Revenue Deficiency

By David Stevens

Two recent Ontario Energy Board decisions underline the risk to applicants who do not file rate applications in a timely fashion. In each of these cases, the OEB allowed increases to amounts charged by the applicants, but also determined that the new amounts would not be effective until after the decision. The result in each case was that the applicant lost the opportunity to collect the increased amounts for the portion of the year that had already passed.

In a March 2015 decision, the OEB determined that the final adjusted 2015 rates for Natural Resource Gas Limited (NRG) would only be effective starting after the decision date, and not for the entire fiscal year. The OEB decided that even though the 2015 rates currently in place for NRG were "interim," the new rates (as increased under a price cap mechanism) would only apply prospectively. The effect is that NRG will only be able to collect the new (higher) rates for the first half of its 2015 fiscal year.

In the NRG decision, the OEB referred to its "long-standing practice of setting rates on a forecast basis" and indicated that its "general practice" is that final rates become effective at the conclusion of a proceeding. Effectively, this means that a proceeding, including any hearing and any Board decision (which may be many months after the hearing) must be complete before the subject year begins. This may prove challenging for complicated proceedings which can take as much as a year from filing date to decision.

The NRG decision follows a November 2014 OEB decision setting Ontario Power Generation "Payment Amounts" for 2014 and 2015. In that decision, the Board found that the effective date for the new Payment Amounts should be November 1, 2014, even though the new Payment Amounts relate to the entire 2014 year. The result was that OPG could not recover the incremental revenue from increased Payment Amounts for most of its 2014 fiscal year.

In the OPG decision, the OEB indicated that where existing rates are declared to be "interim," the OEB has the ability to make final rates effective as of the start of the year (rather than as of the date of decision). It was emphasized, however, that there is no obligation to do that. Indeed, the OEB made clear that its general practice is to make rates effective at the conclusion of the proceeding. The OEB indicated that this is consistent with forward test year ratemaking, and allows utilities and ratepayers to make informed decisions based on approved rates.

A common thread between the NRG and OPG decisions is that the OEB was concerned that the applicant had not filed or completed its application in a timely manner. In each case, the application was not considered complete until just before (in the case of OPG) or after (in the case of NRG) the start of the year to which the new rates would apply. It seems that the lateness of the filings was the biggest factor in the OEB's determination not to backdate the effective date for rates in each case. Clearly this is something to be kept top of mind when preparing rate applications. Filing late creates the risk that the applicant can succeed in obtaining higher rates, yet lose because it is unable to collect those higher rates for a significant portion of the subject year.

Related Blogs

Posted in: Ontario | Practice & Procedure | Energy Policy | Climate Change / Renewables

Insights EnergyInsider
Ontario Takes First Steps to “Cancel” Cap and Trade By David Stevens Jun 19, 2018 In a recent post, we asked what's next under Ontario's new government? It didn’t take long to get a first answer to this question. On June 15, 2018, Ontario’s Premier-designate (Doug Ford) announced “an End to Ontario's Cap-and-Trade Carbon Tax.” According to the news release, “cabinet's first ac...

Posted in: Ontario | Energy Policy

Insights EnergyInsider
What’s Next Under Ontario’s New Government? By David Stevens Jun 11, 2018 On June 7, 2018, Ontario’s Progressive Conservative (PC) party won a majority of seats in the Ontario election. Before the end of June, the PC party will form Ontario’s next government, led by Premier-elect Doug Ford. Over the course of the election campaign, the PC party released its Plan for th...

Posted in: Ontario | Climate Change / Renewables

Insights EnergyInsider
Once Again, All Current Allowances Sold Out in Ontario’s Joint Cap and Trade Auction By David Stevens May 23, 2018 On May 23, 2018, the Ontario government posted the results of the second joint Ontario, Quebec, California auction of greenhouse gas emission allowances, held May 15, 2018. The report shows that all current vintage allowances from each of the three jurisdictions were sold. Additionally, around on...