skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Intellectual Property

Mar 20, 2017

Government of Canada Successful in Eli Lilly NAFTA Patent Arbitration

By Kitt Sinden, M.Sc.

The NAFTA Arbitration Tribunal in the Eli Lilly "Promise of the Patent" doctrine proceeding has issued a ruling, and it appears that the result is not a good one for Eli Lilly.

The proceeding was brought in 2013 by Eli Lilly under Chapter 11 of NAFTA, claiming damages arising from patents relating to atomoxetine (StratteraTM) and olanzapine (ZyprexaTM) that were invalidated by the Canadian courts. Eli Lilly had alleged that the interpretation of the term "useful" in Canada's Patent Act by the Canadian courts, including the Supreme Court of Canada, between 2002 and 2008 violated Canada's obligations under NAFTA. The Government of Canada had argued that Eli Lilly's claims were beyond the jurisdiction of the Tribunal and were wholly without merit as a matter of both fact and law, and has requested that the claim be dismissed and that Eli Lilly be ordered to bear all of its costs in the arbitration.

Initial reports are that the Tribunal has decided in favour of the Government of Canada on the merits and has dismissed Eli Lilly's claim. The decision has not yet been publicly released, so stay tuned as there is plenty more to follow.

Related Categories

Related Blogs

Posted in: Intellectual Property

Insights TheSpotlight
Online Advertising Method Survives Alice at the PTAB By Tony Sabeta, B.Eng. Feb 20, 2018 In 2012, a fledgling startup, AdSupply Inc., filed a patent application for a method for delivering leave behind ads which are displayed behind the browser window when a user leaves a website. These ads are considered to be one of the most effective ad formats for high viewability and user engage...

Posted in: Intellectual Property

Insights TheSpotlight
Patented Love: Our Selection of Innovations for the Romantic at Heart By SuMei Cheung, P.Eng. Feb 14, 2018 With Valentine’s Day upon us, one would rightly suspect that there is already an abundance of patents and patent applications related to online dating software. But if you're really in the mood for love, here are some less obvious technologies dedicated to romance.

Posted in: Intellectual Property

Insights TheSpotlight
Human Rights Complaint on “Chief Wahoo” (Cleveland Indians) Logo to Proceed – Update on Law of Controversial Sports Logos By Ken Clark and Shannon L. Corregan Feb 08, 2018 MLB (or at least the Cleveland Indians) appears to be listening to the winds of change. Last week, on Jan. 29, 2018, the team announced that it would no longer be using the Chief Wahoo logo on their uniforms beginning in 2019. Will this be the first domino in the chain? This case opens up the pos...