skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Ratemaking | Ontario

Sep 21, 2017

OEB Releases Final Report on the Treatment of Pension Costs

By David Stevens and Dillon Collett

The Ontario Energy Board (OEB) released its Final Report on the Regulatory Treatment of Pension and Other Post-employment Benefits Costs (the Report) on September 14, 2017. The Report establishes the use of the accrual accounting method as the default method that rate-regulated entities must use to recover costs incurred from employee pensions and other post-employment benefit costs (OPEBs). The Report also directs utilities to establish a variance tracking account to record the carrying cost associated with any difference between the forecast accrual amounts included in utility rates as compared to actual cash payments made each year. Utilities will be required to credit ratepayers with the carrying costs associated with any positive balance in the variance tracking account (the account will be asymmetric, such that ratepayers will not have to pay carrying charges on negative balances).

As noted in the OEB’s cover letter, the Report is generally consistent with the earlier version of the document that was issued for comment in May 2017. We discussed the earlier version of the Report in our June 8 blog post.

In our earlier post, we described the competing methods of measuring pension and OPEB costs – the cash method and the accrual method. Under the cash method, costs recovered are based on estimated annual employer contributions. The accrual method, on the other hand, uses the standard accounting treatment of pension and post-employment costs, in which employee pension and OPEB costs are recognized when employees render services, rather than when the actual benefits are paid to retirees, or when contributions to the plan are made by the employee.

The OEB has determined that it prefers the accrual method, and will expect all utilities not already on the accrual method to transition away from the cash method in their next cost-based rate application. Utilities proposing to set rates using an alternative method must support their proposal with evidence in relation to the OEB’s policy of setting just and reasonable rates, providing value to customers and ensuring fairness to both present and future ratepayers. Additionally, a utility may request an alternate transition date, supported by compelling reasons, the next time it comes before the OEB with a rates case.

The OEB notes that in some cases the cash amount paid out for pension and OPEB costs can be lower than the amount incurred for accounting purposes, which is what is passed onto ratepayers. In those cases, ratepayers are effectively advancing money to the utility. To address this, the OEB is requiring each utility to establish a variance tracking account to record the amount by which the utility’s accrual costs exceed cash payments. The account will be established on January 1, 2018, and only carrying charges applied to the account will be subject to disposition. Disposition of the carrying charges amounts will occur during the utility’s next cost-based rate application. 

Areas of Expertise

Related Categories

Related Blogs

Directives Issued to IESO and OEB to Prepare Implementation Plans for 2017 LTEP By David Stevens Nov 16, 2017 In late October, Ontario’s Minister of Energy (Glenn Thibeault) issued Directives to the Independent Electricity System Operator (IESO) and the Ontario Energy Board (OEB), requiring each body to prepare “implementation plans” setting out the steps they intend to take to implement the goals and ob...
Ontario Ministry of Energy Proposes Regulatory Changes to Start Implementing 2017 LTEP By David Stevens Nov 15, 2017 As we discussed in an earlier post, many of the new initiatives set out in Ontario’s 2017 Long-Term Energy Plan (2017 LTEP) will require changes to statutes and/or regulations. Late last month, the Ontario Ministry of Energy announced changes to a couple of regulations to begin implementing annou...
Ontario’s New Long Term Energy Plan Stays the Course By David Stevens Nov 01, 2017 On October 26, 2017, Ontario’s Minister of Energy Glenn Thibeault released Ontario’s 2017 Long-Term Energy Plan (2017 LTEP). This long-awaited document is intended to set the course for Ontario’s energy supply over the coming years. While the 2017 LTEP does include some new plans and initiatives,...