skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Energy Policy | Climate Change / Renewables

Jun 29, 2017

California's Supreme Court Confirms Dismissal of Challenge to Cap and Trade Program

By David Stevens

On June 28, 2017, the California Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal of a case that had confirmed the constitutionality of California's Cap and Trade Program. As explained in a news article, this marks the end of the current legal challenges to the Cap and Trade program in California.

As we discussed in an earlier post, the appeal had been brought by the California Chamber of Commerce and was supported by manufacturers and others. At issue in the appeal was whether the auction sale of emissions credits under California’s Cap and Trade program amounts to a tax. If so, then the program would be unconstitutional because it did not receive approval from two-thirds of both houses of the California legislature. On April 6, 2017, the California Court of Appeal for the Third Appellate District had issued a decision dismissing an appeal of a lower court decision that had upheld the constitutionality of California’s Cap and Trade Program. The California Supreme Court’s decision denies any further appeal. This means that California’s Cap and Trade Program will continue under the current legislation. 

In the meantime, the California Legislature is currently considering whether and how to extend the Cap and Trade Program beyond the 2020 expiration date. A recent news report indicates that efforts are continuing to find a way to achieve two-third legislative support to extend California’s Cap and Trade Program and effectively shield the program from future legal challenges. 

The future status of California’s participation in Cap and Trade is important for Ontario, which is planning to join the WCI Cap and Trade auction process in 2018.

Related Blogs

Posted in: Ontario | Energy Policy

Insights EnergyInsider
OEB Publishes Its Strategic Blueprint By David Stevens Dec 21, 2017 Earlier this month, the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) released its Strategic Blueprint for 2017 to 2022. This document, titled “Keeping Pace with an Evolving Energy Sector,” sets out the OEB’s updated statement of “[its] Vision, Mission and Values and of the Goals and Objectives that will guide [its...

Posted in: British Columbia | Facilities | Energy Policy

Insights EnergyInsider
B.C. Decides to Move Ahead with Site C Dam By David Stevens and Nicholas Smith Dec 13, 2017 The Government of British Columbia has decided to proceed with construction of the Site C Dam following its review of the BC Utilities Commission (BCUC) Final Report. In an announcement made on December 11, 2017, Premier John Horgan expressed the difficulty faced by the NDP government in coming t...

Posted in: Climate Change / Renewables | Energy Policy | Ontario

Insights EnergyInsider
Near Sell-Out in the Final Ontario-Only Carbon Credit Auction By David Stevens Dec 12, 2017 On December 6, 2017, the results from Ontario’s final 2017 Cap and Trade Program Auction of Greenhouse Gas Allowances were released. As had been the case for the three previous 2017 auctions, all available current allowances were sold at the November 29, 2017 auction. Additionally, as was the cas...