skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Energy Policy | Practice & Procedure | British Columbia | Facilities

May 26, 2016

B.C. Regulation Exempts Completed Projects from Provincial Environmental Review

By David Stevens

The British Columbia Government's Cabinet recently approved an "exemption regulation" under the Environmental Assessment Act (EAA) that will exempt previously approved and constructed projects from requiring an environmental assessment certificate.

The "exemption regulation" is made in response to the British Columbia Supreme Court (BCSC) decision in Coastal First Nations v. British Columbia (Environment). In that case (as discussed in our prior post), the BCSC set aside an "Equivalency Agreement" between the B.C. Government and the National Energy Board (NEB), pursuant to which the B.C. Government agreed to accept any NEB environmental assessment of an NEB-regulated project. Under the "Equivalency Agreement," there would be no provincial environmental review. The BCSC set aside the "Equivalency Agreement" because it improperly takes away the B.C. Government's obligation to exercise discretion to issue an "environmental assessment certificate" under section 17 of the B.C. Environmental Assessment Act (EAA). The BCSC also indicated that the "Equivalency Agreement" failed to recognize the Province's duty to consult with First Nations.

In practical terms, the "exemption regulation" applies to five NEB-approved projects (Spectra South Peace Pipeline; Nova Gas Transmission Groundbirch Pipeline; Nova Gas Transmission Horn River Mainline Extension; Spectra Dawson Gas Plant; and Spectra Fort Nelson North Plant) that had been treated as being subject to the "Equivalency Agreement" and had not received any B.C. environmental assessment certificate. The stated reason for the exemption of these projects is that it would not be practical or procedurally fair to impose post-construction requirements on these projects.

On the other hand, the "exemption regulation" does not apply to projects that have not yet been constructed, but that had been treated as being subject to the "Equivalency Agreement." This includes the Enbridge Northern Gateway Project (for which a three-year extension to the NEB approval is currently being requested) and the Trans Mountain Expansion Project (which very recently received a recommendation for conditional approval from the NEB). According to the B.C. Government's news release, there will be a process convened by the B.C. Environmental Assessment Office that will make environmental assessment decisions on these projects. This will include consultation with Aboriginal groups. Presumably, these environmental assessment decisions will take the form of either endorsing or adding conditions to any NEB approvals for the projects. Otherwise, as we discussed in our prior post, issues of paramountcy could arise where the B.C. Government decided to deny environmental approval for a project that had already been approved by the NEB.

Related Blogs

Posted in: Ontario | Energy Policy

Insights EnergyInsider
OEB Publishes Its Strategic Blueprint By David Stevens Dec 21, 2017 Earlier this month, the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) released its Strategic Blueprint for 2017 to 2022. This document, titled “Keeping Pace with an Evolving Energy Sector,” sets out the OEB’s updated statement of “[its] Vision, Mission and Values and of the Goals and Objectives that will guide [its...

Posted in: British Columbia | Facilities | Energy Policy

Insights EnergyInsider
B.C. Decides to Move Ahead with Site C Dam By David Stevens and Nicholas Smith Dec 13, 2017 The Government of British Columbia has decided to proceed with construction of the Site C Dam following its review of the BC Utilities Commission (BCUC) Final Report. In an announcement made on December 11, 2017, Premier John Horgan expressed the difficulty faced by the NDP government in coming t...

Posted in: Climate Change / Renewables | Energy Policy | Ontario

Insights EnergyInsider
Near Sell-Out in the Final Ontario-Only Carbon Credit Auction By David Stevens Dec 12, 2017 On December 6, 2017, the results from Ontario’s final 2017 Cap and Trade Program Auction of Greenhouse Gas Allowances were released. As had been the case for the three previous 2017 auctions, all available current allowances were sold at the November 29, 2017 auction. Additionally, as was the cas...