skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Ratemaking | Practice & Procedure | Ontario

Dec 1, 2017

OEB Plans to Introduce “Proportionate Review” of Utility Rate Applications

By David Stevens

A recent webinar presented by Ontario Energy Board (OEB) staff to representatives of Ontario’s electricity distributors (LDCs) sets out the OEB’s plan to link utility performance and regulatory review. As seen in the presentation from the webinar, the OEB intends to employ a more light-handed review process for LDCs who have demonstrated strong performance in relation to the OEB’s “expected outcomes” under the Renewed Regulatory Framework for Electricity Distributors (RRFE). Practically speaking, this means that some utilities will be able to have their rates approved without a hearing, or through an “abridged” hearing process.

The RRFE aims to implement outcomes-based regulation, where customers are assured of value for money. By focusing on results rather than activities in its regulatory oversight, the OEB believes that LDCs will respond to customer preferences, focus on innovation and enhance productivity. The OEB’s planned proportionate review framework is an evolution of this approach. It recognizes that where an LDC’s results (financial, operational, organizational and service) are strong, less review and oversight is required. Effectively, strong-performing utilities will be rewarded by having a less rigorous rate-setting process. The OEB believes that this will allow the regulator to focus regulatory effort where it’s most needed.

The materials from the OEB staff webinar include a slide that illustrates the various “streams” (levels of review) available under the proportionate review framework:

proportionate review framework

Clearly, the choice of which “stream” applies will be very important. This determination will be made by the OEB (presumably based on input and recommendations from OEB staff), and there is no indication that the applicant or other interested parties will have input into or recourse against the decisions made. A slide from the OEB staff webinar sets out the criteria that the OEB will take into account to determine the level of review:

Level of review

The OEB’s new proportionate review framework is currently being piloted, which means that there will soon be some practical information about how the criteria set out above will be considered and applied. All 2018 LDC rebasing applications are being assessed against the criteria in the framework to determine what type of review would be applicable. Additionally, the proportionate review framework is being used for two LDC cost of service applications for 2018, to test and evaluate the concept. The results of this testing will be reviewed in order to make improvements to the proportionate review framework. The OEB is targeting full implementation of the proportionate review framework for all May 1, 2019 LDC rates applications. 

Areas of Expertise

Related Blogs

Posted in: Ontario | Ratemaking | Energy Insider | Consumer Protection

Insights EnergyInsider
OEB Announces Additional RPP Pricing Pilot Program Approvals By David Stevens Feb 06, 2018 The Ontario Energy Board (OEB) has recently announced another participant in its Regulated Price Plan (RPP) pricing pilot program. CustomerFirst will test two different RPP pricing pilots in the service territories of 6 distributors: Newmarket-Tay Power Distribution Ltd., Greater Sudbury Hydro In...

Posted in: Facilities | Canada (Federal) | Ratemaking

Insights EnergyInsider
NEB Denies Request for a Proposed Long-Term Load Retention Service By David Stevens Jan 31, 2018 On January 22, 2018, the National Energy Board released a letter decision denying an application by Maritimes & Northeast Pipeline for approval of a load retention service and reduced toll to Irving Oil Ltd.

Posted in: Ontario | Practice & Procedure | Ratemaking | Facilities

Insights EnergyInsider
OEB Issues Its Largest Rate Case Decision Ever By David Stevens Jan 18, 2018 On December 28, 2017, the Ontario Energy Board (OEB) issued its Decision with Reasons in the Ontario Power Generation “Payment Amounts” case, covering the 2017 to 2021 period. Among the notable determinations are an approval of the forecast costs of the Darlington Refurbishment Project and reduct...