skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Practice & Procedure | Alberta | Consumer Protection

Nov 13, 2015

AUC Approves $56 Million Payment From TransAlta For Price Manipulation

By David Stevens

The Alberta Utilities Commission (AUC) has now approved the payment of $56 million by TransAlta Corporation (TransAlta) as an appropriate sanction for the finding that TransAlta had engaged in conduct that did not support the fair, efficient and openly competitive operation of Alberta's electricity market. We described the AUC's findings in an earlier post.

As described in another earlier post, the $56 million payment is the subject of a settlement between TransAlta and the Alberta Market Surveillance Administrator (MSA). The payment is comprised of disgorgement of economic benefits ($27 million), penalty ($25 million) and payment of MSA investigative costs ($4 million).

The settlement was presented to the AUC by the MSA and TransAlta as part of a Consent Order. After determining that it has jurisdiction to accept the Consent Order, the AUC then addressed whether settlement is in the public interest. The AUC found that a settlement or joint submission on an appropriate penalty should be accepted as long as it falls within a range of acceptable outcomes in the circumstances. It is not appropriate for the AUC to insist upon an outcome that is identical to what it would have fashioned itself. Taking that approach, the AUC found that the Consent Order is in the public interest, and should be approved. In coming to this conclusion, the AUC acknowledged that while the penalty part of the payment ($25 million) is quite high, the seriousness of the contraventions support such a penalty.

As explained in our earlier post, the $56 million payment will go to the Alberta Government's general revenue fund. This is what the Act requires. There will be no direct compensation for affected consumers. It remains to be seen whether there will be any private litigation, such as a class action, seeking consumer compensation.

Related Blogs

Posted in: Ratemaking | Practice & Procedure | Nova Scotia | Facilities

Insights EnergyInsider
Nova Scotia Regulator Approves Smart Meter Project By David Stevens and David Mba Jun 18, 2018 Almost a year after receiving Nova Scotia Power Incorporated’s application, the Nova Scotia Utility and Review Board has approved the $133.2 million Advanced Metering Infrastructure project that is expected to see the installation of 500,000 digital smart meters in Nova Scotia by 2020.

Posted in: Practice & Procedure | Energy Policy | British Columbia

Insights EnergyInsider
B.C. Government to Undertake a Two-Phase Review of BC Hydro’s Costs, Competitiveness and Future By David Stevens and Peter Dalglish Jun 14, 2018 The government of British Columbia announced on June 11, 2018, that advisory groups consisting of government, BC Hydro and “experts” would begin a two-phase review of BC Hydro in an effort to cut costs and reduce rates for consumers, in addition to making the corporation more efficient and compet...

Posted in: Practice & Procedure | Facilities | Canada (Federal) | British Columbia

Insights EnergyInsider
Petronas Invests in British Columbia LNG Project By Zoë Thoms and Peter Dalglish Jun 08, 2018 Less than a year after cancelling the $36-billion Pacific Northwest LNG megaproject in British Columbia, Petronas announced on May 31, 2018, that one of its wholly-owned entities will assume a 25 per cent stake of the LNG Canada project located in Kitimat, B.C.