skip to main content





Back to all Representative Matters
Apr 29, 2013

A&B Successful in Landmark Court of Appeal Decision

Following an eight day Court of Appeal hearing (the longest in that court since 1987), Aird & Berlis LLP lawyer, Chris Matthews, obtained a successful result for Resolute Forest Products (formerly known as Abitibi) in the case of Keewatin v. Minster of Natural Resources and Resolute Forest Products. The Ontario Court of Appeal allowed the appeals of the Ontario Minister of Natural Resources, the Attorney General of Canada and Resolute in a decision released on March 18, 2013.
 
The decision overturns the trial judgment of the Ontario Superior Court. The original decision interpreted Treaty 3 (an Indian treaty from 1873) as requiring federal approval of all land uses, including forestry licences, mining permits and Crown patents, in a 22,000 square kilometre portion of northwestern Ontario, if such uses might interfere with aboriginal hunting and fishing. Given the similarity of wording in other treaties, the decision has the potential to affect existing and future natural resources projects and developments in much of Canada, as well as impact the consultation process with First Nations.
 
The Court of Appeal disagreed with the trial judge and found that Ontario does have the jurisdiction to authorize land uses, and that the treaty language applies to the provincial as well as the federal Crown. The hearing of the appeal involved three appellants, the respondents and six groups of intervenors.

Areas of Expertise

Related Representative Matters

Representative Matters
Mediclean Successful in Tax Court of Canada Louise R. Summerhill and Meghan A. Cowan Apr 17, 2017 Mediclean Inc. was recently successful in winning an appeal in the Tax Court of Canada. Mediclean Inc. had appealed decisions dated March 21, 2016 under the Canada Pension Plan and the Employment Insurance Act that had held that an individual contractor was engaged in pensionable and insurable em...
Representative Matters
Triple M Successful in Tax Court of Canada Louise R. Summerhill and Meghan A. Cowan Feb 06, 2017 Triple M Metal LP was recently successful in winning an appeal in the Tax Court of Canada. Triple M appealed a Notice of Confirmation dated September 15, 2014 relating to an Ontario Goods and Services Tax/Harmonized Sales Tax reassessment covering the period from August 1, 2010 to September 30, 2...
Representative Matters
Supreme Court of Canada Rules in Favour of City of Windsor Christopher J. Williams, Courtney Raphael and Jody E. Johnson Dec 08, 2016 The Supreme Court of Canada today issued its decision in a dispute between the City of Windsor and the Canadian Transit Company (“CTC”). The case, argued on April 21, 2016, was an appeal relating to the jurisdiction of the Federal Court to decide matters involving the applicability of municipal b...