skip to main content
Back to all blog posts

Posted in: Uncategorised | Ontario | Facilities | Climate Change / Renewables

Nov 24, 2015

Environmental Review Tribunal Finds Serious Harm in Settlers Landing Wind Appeal

By Scott Stoll

On November 19, 2015, the Environmental Review Tribunal released a decision in the Settlers Landing Wind Park hearing, finding that elements of the proposed wind project will cause serious and irreversible harm to the natural environment. This is only the second case in which the Tribunal has made such a finding and the first since the Court of Appeal decision in Prince Edward County Field Naturalists v. Ostrander Point GP Inc.

While the Tribunal dismissed several grounds of the appeal, it found that elements of the project, specifically the construction and decommissioning of Turbines 3 and 5 and the construction of certain access roads, will cause serious and irreversible harm to a woodland. Full reasons for the Tribunal's decision were not issued and will follow in the future. This finding engages the Tribunal's authority to revoke the approval, alter the Director's decision (the Renewable Energy Approval) or direct the MOECC Director to take specified actions. It will be interesting to see both the process used by the Tribunal and the ultimate remedy resulting from this decision.

 

Related Blogs

Posted in: Uncategorised

Insights EnergyInsider
Top 10 Posts from 2016: The Year in Review By David Stevens Dec 30, 2016 This has certainly been an eventful year in Canada's energy sector. The many interesting decisions and legal, regulatory and policy developments in diverse areas like climate change, cap and trade, consumer protection and electricity pricing gave us lots to write about. Our Powerful Women series ...

Posted in: Uncategorised

Insights EnergyInsider
EnergyInsider's #Clawbies2016 Nominations Dec 20, 2016 It's time to submit nominations for the 11th annual Canadian Law Blog Awards. Last year, our fellow Aird & Berlis LLP blog StartupSource.ca won in the Best Practice Group Blog Award category. This year we are nominating three blogs that we follow for their interesting perspectives on legal de...

Posted in: Uncategorised

Insights EnergyInsider
A&B's Energy Group Cycling Day - Wisdom, Wheels and Wine By Corrine Kennedy Aug 24, 2016 Attendees at the 5th annual Aird & Berlis Energy Group Cycling Day in Niagara-on-the-Lake enjoyed a brisk cycling tour of Niagara's vineyards, restorative yoga under a mid-day sun, and a culinary and viticultural experience amongst the vines at Inniskillin Winery. Representatives from all are...